Unit 3: Exercise 1: Elina Brotherus Research and Analysis

Reflect on the pieces of work discussed in this project in your learning log and
do some further research of your own.
Here are a few questions you might ask yourself:
● How do these images make you feel?
● Do you think there’s an element of narcissism or self-indulgence in
focusing on your own identity in this way?
● What’s the significance of Brotherus’s nakedness?
● Can such images ‘work’ for an outsider without accompanying text?
● Do you think any of these artists are also addressing wider issues beyond
the purely personal?
Make some notes in your learning log.

Notes:

Elina Brotherus – a finnish photographer and video artist, specialising in self portraits and landscapes. An exploration of herself and as a study of her circumstances – an excellent example of using photography as an investigative tool

Annonciation is a word based on Ennunciation which is the announcement of the birth of Jesus to Mary, a virgin birth. The exhibition called Annonciation in 2004 at The Photographer’s Gallery – London – details her IVF treatment over a 5 year period – the title that refers to Mary’s immaculate conception is in direct contrast to her own experiences

Involuntary childlessness is such a taboo subject still and the artist sets out to break this taboo.

In Elina’s video interview below she mentions that she does not like smiles in a photograph because it fixes the meaning immediately, I have often wondered why many artists do this.

She also uses the body in many of her images but a “showing and hiding” theme such as a steamed up glass showing and hiding parts of the body. An image with a gazing ball is another example


Showing and hiding is a theme in a lot of Elina Brotherus’s work
Showing and hiding – Elina Brotherus

Family portraits have become more thought provoking and honest in some photographers’ work like Sally Mann, Elinor Carucci, Richard Billingham and Tierney Gearon – they have moved from the stereotypical nice cute photos expected in this genre to a more realistic portrayal of family.

How do these images make me feel?

Sadness is the main feeling when looking at her work, the starkness of the interior adds to this feeling but the eyes, sloped shoulders and the artist looking down or her back to the camera portrays negativity. The starkness of the images adds to the sense of loneliness she is feeling and this comes across. The sense of loneliness also comes across with her use of negative space which could be interpreted as voids or literal emptiness in the home where a family should be occupying this physical space.

Annonciation

Do you think there’s an element of narcissism or self-indulgence in
focusing on your own identity in this way?

Yes I do think there is an element of narcissism in these images because they are based totally on herself, however, she has made a point that she hopes these images show the outside world what it’s like when infertility dosen’t work for a large group of people who are overlooked in the media. There is an irony that although the work is focused on herself, many people will be able to relate to this and it may highlight their plight, give other people like her a voice, and create a positive outcome in a change of attitude and support for people in this unfortunate situation.

What’s the significance of Brotherus’s nakedness?

It is as if the artist is allowing the viewer into her personal, private space that is hidden from the outside world when she steps out the door of her home. It could be a glimpse behind the curtain not often seen. The nudity is a shock factor that grabs people’s attention, so if the purpose of the work is to do this, the use of her own naked body in the work will help to achieve this.

Can such images ‘work’ for an outsider without accompanying text?

I don’t think it works for an outsider without accompanying text because there is a specific message the artist wants to communicate to an audience and so the text ensures there is no ambiguity and the message is therefore controlled.

Do you think any of these artists are also addressing wider issues beyond
the purely personal?

Yes I do believe this. She is addressing the lack of support and awareness of the large group of people who are unsuccessful after receiving fertility treatment. She makes the comment that the media only focus on the rare success stories that are more popular.

Elina Brotherus. 2020. Photography — Elina Brotherus. [online] Available at: <http://www.elinabrotherus.com/photography&gt; [Accessed 31 October 2020].

The Phoblographer. 2020. Nudity Pertaining To Photography: Is It Really Necessary? (NSFW). [online] Available at: <https://www.thephoblographer.com/2020/06/04/nudity-pertaining-to-photography-is-it-really-necessary-nsfw/&gt; [Accessed 31 October 2020].

Unit 3 Research: Tierney Gieron: Controversial Family Portraits

An Ameican photographer who has been considered controversial because of candid shots of her children. She shoots life as it happens within her family and often offers very little explanation as to the meaning of the images.

Main bodies of work include:

Explosure

These are double exposure images of the photographer and her family

The Mother Project

With her kids in tow, she chronicled visits to her mom in upstate New York, shooting spontaneously as events occurred, walking in fields, peering or placing herself in quotidian bedroom or bathroom scenes. As she went along, sometimes she would add an element to see what might take place — asking her mom to put on a mask for example — then shoot.

I Am A Camera

This was her first exhibition and it proved very controversial because of the naked images of her children. This is a documented recording of the artist’s family, and were not staged, although props were used and the photos were taken with careful composition in mind. Innocent and grotesque exist alongside each other in many images within this series.

Bibliography

Tierney Gearon Photography. 2020. Bio – Tierney Gearon Photography. [online] Available at: <https://www.tierneygearon.com/bio/&gt; [Accessed 23 October 2020].

Unit 3 Research: Richard Billingham: Squalid Realism

A British photographer who has focused mainly on work of his family, based in the east midlands.

He was the pioneer of squalid realism, documenting the harsh reality of life growing up in a council flat with his alcoholic father in the Black Country. The private part of family suddenly became very public. His photobook called Ray’s a laugh is about a close to home account of his parents. He documented their chaotic life with his camera from a young age. It is a classic depiction of Poverty in Britain in the 1980s. At the time this sort of candid photography was something new and it stood out as shocking.

I find the photos very interesting from a social history perspective, the decor in the flat adds to the overall feeling of deprivation. The way the shots are quite obviously not staged makes them feel somewhat voyeuristic.

The main subject, his parents are the main subject within the image, but there is balance with the numerous other objects in the images that represent the clutter within the house, one even has a cat in it. These are made to feel even more authentic as reality since the parents aren’t posing but going about their lives as if the photographer wasn’t even there. In reality they probably hardly noticed he was there taking photos because his father was drunk most of the time and his mother preoccupied with TV or keeping her husband in check.

Bibliography

Roupenian, K., 2020. A Photographer’S Intimate Self-Portrait Of Womanhood In Middle Age. [online] The New Yorker. Available at: <https://www.newyorker.com/culture/photo-booth/a-photographers-intimate-self-portrait-of-womanhood-in-middle-age&gt; [Accessed 19 October 2020].

Unit 3 Research: Elinor Carucci: Realistic Family Portraiture

American/Israli photographer who uses a family portrait style that is not the stereotypical attractive image but a more realistic approach.

Monograph: a detailed written study of a single specialized subject or an aspect of it.

Her main works are monographs and a great example of self reflection and portraiture.

Closer : (2002) immediate family and closest relationships

This was her first monograph and was produced as a book. It touches on intimacy and mortality. She shows parts of family life that usually stay behind closed doors. She feels that the Israeli culture is more open and receptive to the not so pretty images that her work portrays and the American audience can find them shocking at times. This personal study is honest and takes a look at some of the most painful aspects of living that often are never shown, let alone to the public.

Mother 2013

This work documents pregnancy to the time her children were around 8 years old, a time where they gain independence. This work, as opposed to her previous work forced her outside, following her children. It captures the highs and lows of being a parent. It could also be called a photo diary.

Being a parent makes you see the world through new eyes. Similar to her other works, the everyday is central to her work.

Midlife – 2019

Elinor captures close up magnified parts of her body as well as the seemingly mundane domesticity of her life. The close up images reflects how woman often overthink and magnify imperfections on parts of their body, these show the imperfections that emerge in midlife. The middle aged woman seems to become invisible and this work highlights this and makes them visible again.

Snow and Grey Roots 2015
Mountains on my Hand 2016
Signs of Time 2017
In the Car 2015

Bibliography

Roupenian, K., 2020. A Photographer’S Intimate Self-Portrait Of Womanhood In Middle Age. [online] The New Yorker. Available at: <https://www.newyorker.com/culture/photo-booth/a-photographers-intimate-self-portrait-of-womanhood-in-middle-age&gt; [Accessed 19 October 2020].

A2: Photographing the Unseen: Key Learning Points

The meaning of “Discourse” is explained well by Graham Clarke in his book “The Photograph”:

“That reading (any reading) involves a series of problematic, ambiguous, and often contradictory meanings and relationships between the reader and the image. The photograph achieves meaning through what has been called a ‘photographic discourse‘: a language of codes which involves its own grammar and syntax”.

Use keywords to describe the images you make for your assignments: How to critique a photograph and the language of the photograph is something I am still trying to get to grips with. Using the framework given to me by my tutor should help in my next assignment:

Photographic codes is something new to me, I now understand a little more about this concept, an example about how lighting creates codes, an uplight on a portrait creates a spooky feel to the character, backlight gives glamour and diffused light gives a flattering feel to a portrait.

I am still getting to grips with getting an effective workflow routine where cataloging of photographs so retrieval is possible many years down the line is done effectively.

Theory informs and enriches our practice: The two main writers who discuss the definition of context are Terry Barrett and John A Walker and Bate around the history of photography at three key times, the start in the early 1800’s, the 1920.30’s and the 60’s to 80s, these times in history created theory around the subject and some well known essays from these periods are referenced today by students.

Print out photos at the editing stage to select the best set: A step forward for me this time was to print several of my images and lay them out and re arrange them and see what fits together visually and as a narrative. I looked particularly at a common theme of form and colours in my chosen series. This is something I am just going to have to continue practicing. I re read relevant parts of Jorg Colberg’s book, Understanding Photobooks before starting this process to guide my thinking and refresh myself of the principles involved. I am hoping this becomes more natural to me with practice.

Useful website for photography teachers and students:

https://www.photopedagogy.com/

Photography, The Key Concepts (Bate 2009) – Unit 2 Reading

Feedback from Assignment 2: Photographing the Unseen, was that I need to do more reading around the theory of photography in order to describe my images using the language that relates to the theory around photography practice. I have made notes below on the key points in the suggested reading recommended by my tutor. I am learning that becoming more knowledgeable about the theory will improve my work and ultimately will feed through into my practice, with hard work and consistent application and effort of course.

A short History of Photography Theory

There are three times in history when outbreaks of theory in and on photography have occured:

Late 1830’s when photography was invented

1920’s and 30’s when mass reproduction happened

1960’s, 70’s and the beginning of the 80’s – Postmodernism

Victorian Aesthetics – 1830’s: how far is photography able to copy things accurately? Can we trusty photography as accurate representations of the things they show?

If photography copies things, how can it be art?

The camera requires a creative being to bring it into art, the creative use of technology. This debate, to a certain extent is still around today.

Photography was used for reproducing portraits for the wealthy for the majority of time.

1920’s, 30’s – avant-garde and modern theories exploded and tried to situate photography in new ways. Concepts of montage, realism, formalism, democratic vision, modernism, documentary, political photography, psychical realism, and others were all formed in avant-garde manifestos and by individual writers and photographers.

Walter Benjamin’s “The Work Of Art In The Age Of Mechanical Reproduction” (1936) – A German writer and critic. A key essay from that era of explosion of theory that still survives today.

Famous caption from the essay:

“Earlier much futile thought has been devoted to the question of whether photography is art. The primary question, whether the very invention of photography had not transformed the entire nature of art – was not raised!”

He immediately overturns the 19th century debate.

His arguments and ways of thought went on to influence John Berger’s book “Ways of Seeing” first published in 1972. This book located photography, as it still does today, within our social environment, and showed the massive significance photographic images have in terms of their meaning.

1960’s and 70’s : The Critical Turn: The role of photographic images in the agents of culture (cinema, TV, fashion, marketing, advertising) provoked a range of studies about their significance.

Roland Barthes wrote 2 theoretical essays : “the photographic message” on news photography and “Rhetoric of the Image” on advertising photography.

The new thinking about society and culture in Paris (Structuralism) broke out onto the streets with student revolts in May 1968. In USA civil rights movements raised the issue of race and Women’s rights were raised.

Conceptual photography started challenging the orthodoxies of fine art. Artists began to use and interrogate ways photography had overturned traditional notions of art in the manner that Walter Benjamin inidcated in his 1936 essay “Work of Art” Victor Burgin was probably the most prominent – an English conceptual artist turned to photography as a basis for his own practice – his edited volume of essays in 1982 ” Thinking Photography” brings together some of the key new theoretical arguments about photography during this period.

At the end of the 1980’s photography finally began to be absorbed into art institutions in the way it is seen today – as a dominant modern art form.

Photography theory of this period remains a main reference to this day so it’s worth going into more detail:

The Politics of Representation: The role photos play in social relations? How we see the world? Other people in general or see ourselves? The role of photographs in advertising is controlled by the government. Although we see dozens of photos every day, they seep into our subconscious and it’s easy to forget the impact they have on us.

Louise Althusser, a french philosopher argued that ideology is primarily communicated through images, myths, ideas or concepts in ways that we do not usually think about. Manifested through representation, these ideas are unconscious. Ideology is reproduced through ways in which society represents itself to itself. How are these ideas perpetuated and supported? Often by people or institutions who have least to gain from them. The first serious attempt to develop a systematic theory of the ideology of photography was through the discipline of semiotics,a method of cultural analysis most famously proposed and developed by Roland Barthes during the 1960’s.

Structuralist Theory: Structuralism focuses on structures and systems of rules that underpin and organise any practice, and was based primarily in a new, expanded use of linguistic semiotics. The aim was to find out the grammar of forms, like language.

Semiotics: The Study of Signs: Language helps to construct reality. saussure saw that the work that language does that as securing reality. An image of a man throwing a grenade can be interpreted as a terrorist in one view, and a freedom fighter to another. Language and images are not the passive reflection of a pre-existing “real world” they are the way through which we come to see it as represented as “reality”

Photo Codes: We can vary the perspective codes by “point of view” Different genres of photography tend to emphasise different aspects of codes.Lighting is culturally coded, a direction of light has meaning, ie. top light can signify “other worldly” feel or angelic innocence. Move the light behind the head and you have glamour photography, and bottom light makes a face look devilish. a street lamp at night gives a dark moody scene, not ideal for a wedding for example.

Rhetoric: in terms of photography, defines the organisation of codes into an argument. Rhetoric is the art of persuasion and aims to move, please and instruct. Separate codes are meaningless like individual letters in an alphabet, but when combined effectively they have meaning, and we make a “good” or effective photograph. It is from a particular configuration of such codes that the rhetoric of the image determines the range of meaning available from the photograph.

Realism vs Semiotics,they are both two different theories of photography that can be drawn upon when making work.

Teaching About Photography: Photographs and Contexts (Terry Barrett)

Terry Barrett, Art Education July 1986

This article is suggested reading from my tutor in response to the submission of my second assignment, Photographing the Unseen. I have made notes of the key parts of this article below:

Viewers who want to understand and appreciate a photograph need to see what fresh and significant relationships the photographer may have brought about and the means used to make them manifest. Considering context allows this.

Context can be “INTERNAL” “ORIGINAL” or “EXTERNAL”

Internal Context:

Description and analysis of what is seen in the photograph – identification of hte subject matter, consideration of its form and relationships between the two

Photography brings its own set of formal elements and terms, beyond those shared with paintings and drawings and need to be learned and investigated. Focus, dept of field, angle of view, shutter speed, types of illumination, grain size, tonality, contrast range shoudl be explored to see how they effect the subject matter and form and how form and subject combine to express.

Not all photographs can be understood and appreciated solely on the basis of what is shown.

Original Context

These are photographs that need outside contextual information to understand the image.

Original context is information drawn from sources outside the photograph that, if used, adds meaning and therefore a fuller appreciation. It is information that was physically and psychologically present to the photographer at the time the photo was made.

A good example of an image that benefits from original context is the famous image of a naked girl and soldiers fleeing from smoke and running towards us. Knowledge of the circumstances around this photograph is what makes it powerful, the original context is that the girl is Viatnamese and she is burning so has torn away her clothing because she has just been sprayed with napalm. It is about the US involvement in the Vietnam war. This knowledge could never have been gained by simply viewing the image.

Nick Ut’s “Napalm Girl” is an example of how original context is needed to understand the image

External Context

Refers to the photographer’s presentational environment:

How and where it is being, has been presented

Received

How other interpreters have understood it

Where it has been placed in the history of art

Robert Doisneau’s Photograph: external context has radically altered its meaning

Robert Doisneau, Paris Cafe 1958

5 places (external contexts) for this photograph:

Photo was published in a magazine called Le Pont, devoted to cafes

This photo ended up in a small brochure about the evils of alcohol abuse

French scandal newspaper : “Prostitution on the Champs- Elysees”

Since this misinterpretation this image has also appeared in the Museum of Modern Art in New York and

Szarkowski’s (1973) Looking at Photographs: 100 Pictures from the collection of the Museum of Modern Art

No photograph is presented without context.

Summary / My Thoughts

When presenting my assignments I need to think about and describe the context more accurately. Using the knowledge from this article and others given to my by my tutor has helped me to understand why it is so important to describe the context of the images I make.This is something I need to practice doing so my assignments improve.